Relevant data point: My 205/45-16 BFG SC2's are nearly ready for replacement after 12k miles (not quite at the wear bars, but can feel a slight loss of total grip. 60/30/10%, hwy/streets/canyons. Best grip, for me, found at 39front/36rear)
Compare/Contrast
-Significantly more ride comfort than OEM 17
-Noticeable loss of steering response but no less precise
-More grip than OEM 17's with 17k miles (apples to zebras)
-Excellent dry and wet grip
-Noisier than OEM (that means it grips harder, right?
-Dirt cheap ($85 per)
-Not light/not heavy (21lbs)
Going to get Indy 500s for my next set. Not because the BFG SC2 are not a great value, but it's fun to try something new. Also, 500s are same price, lighter and great (better?) reviews.
EDIT: mounted on 16x7 Maxxim Winner