The problem with the people that are blasting you is that they are likely just daily driving their car. So from a cost to performance ratio, yes it isn't really worth it. And most being daily drivers they don't want to deal with losing creature comforts. But for a weekend warrior/ track car I can't see why you wouldn't want to weight reduction especially on a stock engine. You keep all the stock reliability and gain acceleration, handling, braking. Less weight means less wear which leads to less cost. You could easily drop around 200 pounds from a completely stock ST for free if you had no concern for comfort.
This is true, as look at how most on here complain about a non-cushy ride, and then also add in sometimes
over 100 lbs. of in car entertainment electronics, so then their only choice for improved acceleration is moar powah.
I purposely and intentionally ordered this car from the factory with the base seats (with
possible plans for future racing shell type seats in the future), and no sunroof (less chance for leaks/rattles as well).
Then I mostly gutted the whole hatch area, save for the rear door cards, and the little bit of liner 'carpet', and plastic on the quarter panel sides, and the spare/jack (since it IS a daily driver, and I do not want to wait for half a day for AAA to tow me home if I get a flat).
The bracing that everyone is so enamored of on here also adds heft (
even if it does actually make a difference), and yes, I am slightly guilty of that as well since I have the (less than??) 3 lb. Swave alloy trunk brace going in today.
But, as far as the whole drivetrain system taking less stress (as well as lesser 'consumables' co$t$) with greatly reduced weight, that cannot be argued against,
at all.
Back when 4th gen f bodies (Camaro/Firebird) were still a thing, there were those who put fully built, 550 HP+ NA engines, or even more powerful built twin turbo system setups into those almost 3700 lb. (when fully loaded) rides, and then added in 250 lbs. of audio/video on top of that.
They then wondered why they were grenading the already too weak to even handle the factory power LS1s at even a base car's weight, 10 bolt rear axles, and twisting and shearing the factory driveshafts, on not even the stickiest of rear tires.