• Sign Up! To view all forums and unlock additional cool features

    Welcome to the #1 Fiesta ST Forum and Fiesta ST community dedicated to Fiesta ST owners and enthusiasts. Register for an account, it's free and it's easy, so don't hesitate to join the Fiesta ST Forum today!


Repairable?

TyphoonFiST

9000 Post Club
Premium Account
Messages
11,708
Likes
8,213
Location
Rich-fizzield
#2
Depends on the frame,. Unibody frames are delicate and it doesn't take much. Its hard to tell a price until the condition of the frame is determined by a body shop.
 


Messages
306
Likes
340
Location
Virginia
#4
Depends on the frame,. Unibody frames are delicate and it doesn't take much. Its hard to tell a price until the condition of the frame is determined by a body shop.
Yep, doors are no big deal. Airbags add some cost, but still not the end of the world. The frame is what will determine if it’s even possible. Second time my ‘15 was rear ended, the frame was not repairable in any way that would be legal. Cost didn’t matter.
 


Dpro

6000 Post Club
Messages
6,361
Likes
5,982
Location
Los Feliz (In the City of Angels) aka Los Angeles
#5
This looks a bit concerning as at the top of the door right where it meets the rear quarter window there looks like there might be a kink in the roof. Followed by a visible indent in the roof above your quarter window . Add to that the damage across the rocker at the bottom underneath suggests the unibody is pushed inwards at an angle on that side. Which would translate to it not being straight front to rear. That pretty much means its screwed.
Now this is just from looking at it a body shop could more accurately asses it . I can tell you though having fixed cars in the past I would not be surprised if they told its done.
 


XR650R

2000 Post Club
Premium Account
Messages
2,716
Likes
3,152
Location
Eerie
#6
Welcome!
Like everybody said, you need a pro to look at it. Let us know what they say.
 


Ford ST

2000 Post Club
Messages
2,925
Likes
3,065
Location
Pleasant Garden
#7
Potential cost well over $5,000 easy. Insurance would total that car out in a heartbeat.

Fixable and structurally sound only a pro can tell you that.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 


Messages
492
Likes
518
Location
Wichita, KS, USA
#8
Take it to a shop, get it thoroughly looked at - if the estimator is willing to walk you through what they see and what it will take to repair/replace the parts, even better. Just from the picture it looks like a couple doors and airbag(s), but you want a pro to look at it and tell you what can be done.
 


Messages
306
Likes
340
Location
Virginia
#9
Potential cost well over $5,000 easy. Insurance would total that car out in a heartbeat.

Fixable and structurally sound only a pro can tell you that.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
To "total" a car, at least in the US, that means damages exceed the value of the car. Last I checked, the FiST hadn't quite dropped down to $5k. Damages over $10k, maybe.

Possible exceptions for damage that can't be legally repaired (cutting out sections of the frame, for example).
 


Ford ST

2000 Post Club
Messages
2,925
Likes
3,065
Location
Pleasant Garden
#10
To "total" a car, at least in the US, that means damages exceed the value of the car. Last I checked, the FiST hadn't quite dropped down to $5k. Damages over $10k, maybe.

Possible exceptions for damage that can't be legally repaired (cutting out sections of the frame, for example).
Definitely not correct. Look at the picture below and tell me what you think. They gave me over $5,000 for it because they totaled it out. No airbags were deployed.

I don't live in the UK I don't know how the laws work when it comes to insurance, or what is allowed with the inspections I know they have.



"If the cost of repairing your vehicle exceeds a certain percentage of your car's value before the accident, insurance companies will declare it a "total loss." Some car insurance companies will total a vehicle if damages are at or above 51% its pre-accident value. Other insurers will total at 80%. State insurance departments often set guidelines for the percentage at which cars can be totaled."

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.insure.com/amp/car-insurance/car-totaling.html

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 


Last edited:

SteveS

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,445
Likes
1,717
Location
Osage Beach, MO, USA
#11
What totals a car is based on what it takes to require the car to have a salvage title. In Missouri, that level is 80% of the value prior to the accident. Right now, most Fiesta STs are selling for anywhere from $13000 to $19000 depending on mileage. The insurance company will likely choose a value that's in their favor, so perhaps $14000. 80% of that is $11200.

So, at least in Missouri, for a Fiesta ST in good condition and not with tons of miles, it wouldn't get totaled until perhaps $10000 of damage. That said, it doesn't seem to take much to reach $10000 given the costs of professional body work.
 


Ford ST

2000 Post Club
Messages
2,925
Likes
3,065
Location
Pleasant Garden
#12
It sure doesn't my fender cost almost $1,500 to replace with paint.
With airbags it gets expensive fast.



Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 


Messages
306
Likes
340
Location
Virginia
#13
Definitely not correct. Look at the picture below and tell me what you think. They gave me over $5,000 for it because they totaled it out. No airbags were deployed.

I don't live in the UK I don't know how the laws work when it comes to insurance, or what is allowed with the inspections I know they have.



"If the cost of repairing your vehicle exceeds a certain percentage of your car's value before the accident, insurance companies will declare it a "total loss." Some car insurance companies will total a vehicle if damages are at or above 51% its pre-accident value. Other insurers will total at 80%. State insurance departments often set guidelines for the percentage at which cars can be totaled."

That's an 08'+ Ford Focus? I'd say $5k was a pretty fair total loss valuation, assuming that was in the last few years.

As pointed out, it does vary by state, but if you've got an insurance company that's going for a "total out" at 50% value (likely the legal minimum in some states), you need a new insurance company.

Second time I had my FiST rear-ended, they estimated about $12k in repairs to fix it. They would have given the green light to repairs, only issue is those repairs wouldn't have been legal pretty much anywhere, so it was listed as a total loss, and Geico paid me $15,900 for it. This was about two years ago.

Also, you may have the option to contest the insurance company's valuation, which most people don't realize. I've been through this ordeal. Twice. Don't settle for what the insurance company gives you; you may have better options. Geico just happened to offer me top of market for my '15 at the time, so I opted not go that route.
 


Ford ST

2000 Post Club
Messages
2,925
Likes
3,065
Location
Pleasant Garden
#14
That's an 08'+ Ford Focus? I'd say $5k was a pretty fair total loss valuation, assuming that was in the last few years.

As pointed out, it does vary by state, but if you've got an insurance company that's going for a "total out" at 50% value (likely the legal minimum in some states), you need a new insurance company.

Second time I had my FiST rear-ended, they estimated about $12k in repairs to fix it. They would have given the green light to repairs, only issue is those repairs wouldn't have been legal pretty much anywhere, so it was listed as a total loss, and Geico paid me $15,900 for it. This was about two years ago.

Also, you may have the option to contest the insurance company's valuation, which most people don't realize. I've been through this ordeal. Twice. Don't settle for what the insurance company gives you; you may have better options. Geico just happened to offer me top of market for my '15 at the time, so I opted not go that route.
I have Geico and I was very happy to get ,$5,000 for that car. That was in September of 2020. 2010 SE 123,000 miles.
You were completely wrong in your first post. I don't need to be told how it works because I know how it works.


"To "total" a car, at least in the US, that means damages exceed the value of the car." Your words not mine. Wrong just say it. Wrong about the value and wrong by saying US when insurance is done by state.

Who in the hell wants a car fixed with structural damage anyway? $12,000 for being rear ended I wouldn't want to drive that car even if it was legal.

I'm not trying to be a jackass but I don't play being told I'm wrong when I'm not.



Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 


Last edited:
Messages
306
Likes
340
Location
Virginia
#15
Never said you were wrong, I just tried to clarify my over-simplification of the issue of "totaling". As I said, that was the estimate, the repairs would have been illegal, I was happy to get what I did, but there are usually options if you are not. There was no further subtext behind my posts.
 


Ford ST

2000 Post Club
Messages
2,925
Likes
3,065
Location
Pleasant Garden
#16
Never said you were wrong, I just tried to clarify my over-simplification of the issue of "totaling". As I said, that was the estimate, the repairs would have been illegal, I was happy to get what I did, but there are usually options if you are not. There was no further subtext behind my posts.
It is all good I have been through this twice in the last year so I just know how it works. Never my fault mother nature seems to hate my vehicles.

A quick example to your point though another individual with a Ford Focus like I had only got $1,000. He would have bought the car back but the state he lives in Georgia does not allow you to title a salvaged vehicle.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 


Dpro

6000 Post Club
Messages
6,361
Likes
5,982
Location
Los Feliz (In the City of Angels) aka Los Angeles
#17
Like others have said and is true as I have seen the average total is a repair bill that comes up to 80% of the Value including labor.

While lots can speculate what constitutes what a FiST would total for there are a lot of variables.

Mileage on the car having a big factor. The higher the mileage the more likely to total. On top of that you would be surprised how little trim pieces you can get for fairly cheap magically jump in value on a estimate. This again is an age mileage factor.

Newer car they will specify brand new parts at dealer list. Older car they will use junk yard or used parts when they can. This again is age/Value factor. Even though they opt to use used parts the car could still total out though.

The OP’s car easily has 5k or more in repairs labor hours wise as the Whole side of the car pretty much has to be resprayed paint wise. That is more labor time plus supplies. Though if is unibody is bent like I speculate based on the pics that could easily total it because a side hit punch to the unibody is really almost impossible to straighten correctly . Its like permanently warped.
Yes fixed a lot of cars and been around a lot of body shops. Its not always cut and dry which
 


Messages
256
Likes
229
Location
Vancouver
#18
Like others have said and is true as I have seen the average total is a repair bill that comes up to 80% of the Value including labor.

While lots can speculate what constitutes what a FiST would total for there are a lot of variables.

Mileage on the car having a big factor. The higher the mileage the more likely to total. On top of that you would be surprised how little trim pieces you can get for fairly cheap magically jump in value on a estimate. This again is an age mileage factor.

Newer car they will specify brand new parts at dealer list. Older car they will use junk yard or used parts when they can. This again is age/Value factor. Even though they opt to use used parts the car could still total out though.

The OP’s car easily has 5k or more in repairs labor hours wise as the Whole side of the car pretty much has to be resprayed paint wise. That is more labor time plus supplies. Though if is unibody is bent like I speculate based on the pics that could easily total it because a side hit punch to the unibody is really almost impossible to straighten correctly . Its like permanently warped.
Yes fixed a lot of cars and been around a lot of body shops. Its not always cut and dry which
lol, it's not permanently warped, any reputable body shop equipped with laser measuring system, frame rack, and hydraulic pullers can repair that. That looks totally repairable, You're b-pillar definitely will need to be pulled. New quarter panel sectioned in. Rocker can be pulled. You need a new door. The issue is you're airbags went off, which is what will likely total your car. The srs module and replacement of your seat belt tensioners is what will drive the cost up as the srs modules and safety related parts are usually the most expensive parts.
 


Dpro

6000 Post Club
Messages
6,361
Likes
5,982
Location
Los Feliz (In the City of Angels) aka Los Angeles
#19
lol, it's not permanently warped, any reputable body shop equipped with laser measuring system, frame rack, and hydraulic pullers can repair that. That looks totally repairable, You're b-pillar definitely will need to be pulled. New quarter panel sectioned in. Rocker can be pulled. You need a new door. The issue is you're airbags went off, which is what will likely total your car. The srs module and replacement of your seat belt tensioners is what will drive the cost up as the srs modules and safety related parts are usually the most expensive parts.
I did not say it was not repairable I said almost and yes the unibody is quite possibly warped. I said possibly as in I speculate that is not a for certain as when one speculates its means they are making a somewhat educated guess that is not for sure.



I also pointed out all the ins and outs of said possibility.
I also said none of us can actually know for sure twice and that it was really up to a professional.

Again like I said it all comes down to added up costs . A car can be totally fixable but cost to much to warrant repairing it and get totaled. I see that all the time when I go to the junkyard.

Also regardless of what you think I have seen cars that should not have been repaired unibody hits that are back on the road and not driving right because of it.

Anybody can try and fix anything it may or may not come out right though. :LOL:
 


Last edited:
OP
Z

Zshadow89

New Member
Messages
2
Likes
1
Location
Swindon, UK
Thread Starter #20
Well update, as many of you suggested , it got written off my insurance company.
A shame. Im sure it'll be back on the roads one day though
Leads to my next question but off topic.
Do you recommend GAP insurance?
 


Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
I Want To Buy 0

Similar threads



Top