Weathertechs are great. I opted for the Husky Liners instead because the rear one is a single piece over the hump and I have kids, so the extra protection was worth it. It was a bit of a bear to stuff under the back edge of the console though. Definitely love them. They fit incredibly well and my carpets look like new under them. They look perfectly fine in the car too.
Huskys are a bit cheaper and offer slightly better coverage in the rear, but the Weathertechs are a bit nicer fit and finish (very marginal). I'm very happy with my choice. I can snap some pics tonight if you're interested.