For a
500 tread wear rated, all season tire they are pretty damned good!
Truly a mistake to compare them to ANY actual,
summer ONLY, UHP/Max performance tire.
About the only better handling in the warm/dry 'all season' labeled donut out there is the 280 tread wear, Nitto Neo Gen, but I would be VERY hesitant to take those out in even 1/16th of an inch of snow, whereas I've had the Pilot Sport AS/3s out in up to an inch, and did not feel my life was in danger.
(YUP,
NEITHER should be used in any
real snow, but in an emergency, I'd trust the Michelins over all of the rest, save for maybe the Conti DWSes, or whatever they call their latest/greatest all season, which is not even made in our exact OEM size anyway.)