what determines a tire being too high? guessing ride height and how soft springs are.
also not sure how high is too high
Stock tire is 23.4" tall. Fenders have enough clearance at stock height for right at/under 23.8" tall tire. Lowering can bring up challenges with this size.
Too high is anything over 23.8" from what ive seen. Hence why people either go shorter at 23" or so(205/50R15, 225/45R15, 205/45R16) or slightly above at 23.6"(215/45R16). The tallest i think that we can run currently is 215/40R17 at 23.8" tall without rubbing(depending on wheel offset and lowering amount). 24"+ tall tires are just too tall/wide(most are 235+ in width) to fit under the stock fenders but some have made them fit with flares and some cutting. Some have tried the 225/45R16 size and either had zero issues or rubbed badly. So that is up for debate.
The widest tire that I know fits without rubbing, without flares or beating the interior of the wheel wells up is a 225/45R15 on a 15x8 +35mm.
I haven't seen anyone try a 245/40R15 yet but it could fit knowing its a 23" tall tire that can fit on an 8" wheel. Offset and camber would be key to ensuring it does not rub the strut housing, spring or fender liners.
Most track guys run 205/50R15, 225/45R15, 215/45R16, 205/40R17 or 215/40R17 as they are commonly available extreme performance tire sizes. Wheels are 15x7(common), 15x8(hard to get), 16x7(common), 16x7.5(a few choices), 16x8(Dekagrams), 17x7(good amount of choices), 17x7.5(a few choices) and 17x8(a few choices).
If i have something wrong someone will correct me but i think that encapsulates alot of it.