I also think the shifter is fine: the feel of a control is obviously subjective. I collected a bunch of road tests while deciding and waiting on my car, this discussion got me curious and I looked back at what some automotive journalists said about our shifter.
Auto Express: A brilliant gearbox features a precise, short-throw shift action.
Motor Trend: a great shifter
Rallyways: I feel the shifter lever is a little lower than I would like. ... Having said what I said about the shift lever position, it is a buttery smooth and joyful shift lever to operate. While I still prefer the feel of a gear shifter that goes straight into the transmission, as is the case with rear-wheel drive cars, this one is the next best thing. For a remote shifter, the shifting action is a beautiful thing. Did I say how nice this thing is to shift? Lovers of the manual transmission rejoice!
Evo: The gearshift is slick, precise, with a well-defined gate, satisfying to shift. Our long termer feels better still - the miles have given the lever an even slicker action.
Jalopnik: Transmission?s superb, clutch perfectly weighted with a nice, well-defined catch point, throws light and crisp, could be a bit shorter, a supremely easy 6MT to operate.
Moto IQ: The FiST has fairly decent stock shift feel, which is quite positive for a cable shifter FWD car.
Automobile: ...clean shift action from the six-speed manual.